One of the most criminally overlooked, even by the clichéd standards, the band Big Star truly defined the tragic indie band’s aura. After three albums (the first two of which Bell was a driving force behind), Bell disappears and winds up passing away tragically in a car accident after grappling with depression. Bell’s influence can heard on one of the most instantly likable and singable tunes. On their debut #1 Record, Bell’s tune “Thirteen†has a syrupy sweet acoustic melody that’s both instantly catchy and lyrically simple (even though Alex Chilton sang it, the tune sounds much more like Bell’s work).
The original “I Am the Cosmos†would not see the light of day until 14 years after his death. While Chilton went on to be a productive (if supremely uneven and troubled) songwriter, Bell left few gems for his followers. The instant classic on the deluxe edition is “You and Your Sister.†It’s innocent lyrics and simple acoustic guitar picking echo “Thirteen†and “I’m In Love with a Girl.†The simplicity and rather nasal quality of Bell’s voice give the song a rather fragility. Bell’s earnestness feels authentic in every way (even with a rather subtle echo vocal effect). It’s as though Bell is singing and playing alone in a cavernous hallway and the effect is tragic.
While the rest of the record yields generally interchangeable remixes and alternate versions, the vaults had some small treasures. His collaboration with Memphis Songwriter Keith Sykes “Stay With Me†is a piece of rough around the edges pop that is undeniably catchy. The somewhat plodding “In My Darkest Hour†is a collaboration with Nancy Bryan. It’s a bit too much of Bryan’s singing that really undercuts the authentic emotion of Bell’s singing.
While the deluxe edition does not offer a completely new portrait of Bell’s talents, it simply refines them. His diverse styles and Beatlesque vocals (albeit more idiosyncratic) certainly suggest a second look. Bell’s musical talents were never quite realized publicly during his lifetime, but the new edition displays a rounded package. Sometimes if you strive to be your idols (some form of the Beatles), you may start a new movement yourself. Indie powerpop would not be the same without Bell’s hands on it. This record and Big Star’s first two are the proof.
About the author: Jeff is a teacher in the Boston area. When not buried correcting papers, Jeff can be found plucking various stringed instruments and listening to all types of americana music.