When a critic hears about a new act in music, a relative unknown, often the excitement at discovery is tempered by trepidation at the disappointment. Still, as music writers we attempt to somehow divide our time between trusted acts, the possibility of a new discovery that no one else has heard.

With these same ambivalent emotions, I dove in to Plain & Simple (Billy Purnell’s) self-produced album. The title “Plain & Simple” fits the music well. Purnell’s rhythmic guitar work and scratchy vocals lend the record a blue collar feel. He seems most comfortable picking out a guitar break.

Purnell seems a bit stuck in the post-Pearl Jam Eddie Vedder vocal crowd. While occasionally a more natural feel comes out, Purnell’s voice tends to create a rather grating 1995 scratchy sound.

That said, Purnell has a nice rollicking Americana guitar sound with some catchy melodies (most sticking to the minor). It’s hard to tell in some songs whether or not Purnell means them in gest or not. Assuming so, the lyrics hint at the shovanistic bravado rampant in the south. Purnell hails from rural Missouri.

Purnell has written some catchy choruses particularly “Black & Mild.” The closing track builds an interesting narrative about a woman stuck in her circumstances. The chorus “Hold on to me one more time now / Take me out of this place / Can’t you see that I need you tonight / Need to feel your embrace.” The classic theme rings true. Purnell has managed to strike a nice balance.

Purnell’s first offering, though quite rough, shows promise. With toned down vocals, and spruced up arrangements, the melodies could perhaps shine a bit brighter. Purnell has begun the story but certainly hasn’t finished it yet.

About the author:  Jeff is a teacher in the DC metro area. When not buried correcting papers, Jeff can be found plucking various stringed instruments and listening to all types of americana music.

by Jeff McMahon in Reviews